Articles:
Wrong to recognise Kosovo
19.02.08 Publication: Corriere della Sera
The declaration of independence by Kosovo at the weekend, and the resulting split inside the European Union over whether to give official recognition to the new nation-state, represents a big failure for
The hard truth is that Kosovo’s declaration of independence, and the recognition of it by other countries, is in violation of international law as laid down in the United Nations charter and UN precedent. There has been no resolution by the Security Council to give a mandate to that recognition, because
How, now, can these two competing truths be reconciled? What attitude should European governments take to Kosovo? The answer, surely, is that the European Union should defend international law on this issue, and so its member governments should not give Kosovo formal recognition. Kosovo is, as European Union officials and Kosovo’s British, French and Italian supporters argue, a special case: it has been a protectorate for more than eight years and is a relic of a sovereign entity that no longer exists, namely
At the same time, without providing Kosovo with official recognition, the EU can and should proceed with its mission there, taking over the UN’s duties by sending 1,800 police and justice officials, to work alongside the 17,000-strong NATO security force. That mission is legal, having been mandated by Security Council resolution no 1244 back in 1999. To deny recognition while also sending the mission will not be a clean or neat formula; it would not, as many European officials hope, bring about the final resolution of Kosovo’s political status. But that would be true with the alternative too, with some European countries going ahead with recognition. That will perpetuate the bitter argument with
It would be far better to accept that a full solution is going to take longer. In practice, it is not going to happen until